A quote arrives. It says FOB Guangzhou. You compare it against another quote that says EXW and a third that says DDP, and the three numbers are different — so you assume the cheapest one is the best one.
Then the invoice arrives with origin charges, terminal handling, a customs broker fee and a destination charge that nobody mentioned, and the cheapest quote turns out to have been the most expensive.
The Incoterm was not a detail on the quote. The Incoterm was the quote.
This is what the common terms actually mean, which costs each one includes, where the risk moves, and the one line that decides more disputes than any other: the point at which the goods stop being the supplier's problem.
What an Incoterm is — and the three things it isn't
Incoterms are published by the International Chamber of Commerce. They are three-letter codes that fix, for a given shipment, three things:
- Which party arranges and pays for each stage — export clearance, main carriage, insurance, import clearance, final delivery
- At which physical point the risk of loss or damage transfers from seller to buyer
- Which party is responsible for the paperwork at each stage
They do not cover three things buyers routinely assume they do.
They don't transfer ownership. Title is set by your contract and your payment terms, not by the Incoterm. Goods can be shipped DDP and still legally become yours only once they're paid for.
They don't say anything about quality. A DDP shipment can be entirely defective. Incoterms move goods and risk; they do not define acceptance criteria.
They don't tell you the price. An FOB price and a DDP price for the same garment are not comparable numbers, because they buy different things.
That last point is the one that costs buyers the most money, so it's worth restating: you cannot compare quotes that sit under different Incoterms. Convert them to the same basis first, or you're comparing the cost of two different journeys.
The two columns that matter: cost and risk
Every Incoterm answers two questions, and the answers don't always move together.
Cost: who pays for what.
Risk: from which moment is a lost or damaged shipment your loss rather than the supplier's.
Most buyers only read the first column. The second is where the expensive surprises live — because a term can have the seller paying the freight while the risk has already passed to you. That combination exists, it is common, and it is the single most misunderstood thing in the system.
The terms you'll actually see
EXW — Ex Works. The supplier makes the goods available at their premises. Everything after that is yours: loading, inland transport, export clearance, ocean freight, insurance, import clearance, delivery. Least work for the supplier, most work for you.
EXW looks cheap on a quote and is almost never right for a buyer without a forwarder already in place. It also has an awkward edge: export clearance is technically the buyer's responsibility, in a country where the buyer may not be able to file it.
FOB — Free On Board. The supplier clears the goods for export and loads them onto the vessel at the named port. From the moment they're on board, cost and risk are yours.
This is the standard basis for Chinese apparel exports, and for good reason: it puts the part of the journey the supplier controls under the supplier, and the part the buyer can control — the ocean leg and destination — under the buyer. If you have your own forwarder and a freight rate you like, FOB is usually the right answer.
CFR — Cost and Freight. Same as FOB, except the supplier also pays ocean freight to the destination port. Risk still transfers when the goods are loaded at origin. The supplier is paying for a journey during which the cargo is already your risk.
CIF — Cost, Insurance and Freight. CFR plus marine insurance arranged by the supplier. Same risk transfer point: at origin, on board.
This is the trap. See below.
DAP — Delivered at Place. The supplier delivers to a named place — often your warehouse — with the goods ready for unloading. The buyer handles import clearance and duties. The supplier carries the risk all the way to that address.
DDP — Delivered Duty Paid. The supplier does everything, including import clearance and paying duty and tax. Maximum convenience for the buyer, maximum exposure for the supplier, and usually a higher headline price because the supplier is pricing a risk and a cash-flow burden, not just a service.
The CIF trap
CIF is the term most often misunderstood, and the misunderstanding is expensive.
Under CIF, the supplier arranges and pays the freight and the insurance. It is very easy to read that as "the supplier is responsible until the goods arrive." They are not.
Under CIF, risk transfers to you when the goods are loaded on board at the port of shipment. If the vessel sinks in the Indian Ocean, the loss is yours — and your recourse is the insurance policy, not the supplier.
Two consequences follow:
- The insurance under CIF is minimum cover by default — typically Institute Cargo Clauses (C), which excludes a long list of perils. Broader cover has to be agreed and paid for.
- The claim is yours to file. The supplier's obligation was to arrange cover, not to run the claim.
If you're going to use CIF, read the insurance clause before the goods move, not after. And if you're arranging your own cover anyway — which most repeat importers do — plain CFR is the cleaner basis.
The costs that live outside the term
This is why two FOB quotes can still produce different landed costs. The Incoterm defines a boundary, but there are charges on both sides of it that don't always appear in the quote.
On the origin side:
- Export documentation and customs declaration
- Inland haulage from factory to port
- Origin terminal handling charges
- Container loading and any consolidation
- Export inspection, where the destination market requires it
On the destination side:
- Destination terminal handling charges
- Customs brokerage
- Import duty and VAT or sales tax
- Delivery from port to warehouse
- Demurrage and detention, if the container sits
The practical discipline: ask for a landed cost breakdown, not a unit price. A supplier who can show you where the boundary sits — and what's on each side of it — is a supplier who has actually shipped before.
Which term at which stage
First order, small volume, no forwarder: DDP or DAP is often worth the higher headline number, because it removes a category of work you're not set up to do and a category of surprise you can't price. You are paying for simplicity, and on a first order that is usually a fair trade.
Once you have a forwarder and a freight rate: move to FOB. The total is usually lower, and you get visibility on the ocean leg that you don't have when someone else books it.
Larger, regular volumes: FOB with your own consolidation — and your own cargo insurance regardless of the term.
Never: EXW, unless you already have an agent in the origin country handling export clearance. It is a term designed for a buyer with infrastructure, and it is often quoted by suppliers who would rather not be responsible for the port.
What to write into the order
Incoterms 2020 requires the term plus a named place. "FOB" alone is not a term — it is the start of an argument.
Write:
- The term and the named port or place. "FOB Ningbo" and "DDP Los Angeles, CA 90021" are complete. "FOB China" is not.
- The Incoterms version. 2020 is current; older contracts still reference 2010, and the differences matter.
- Who books the freight, where it isn't implied by the term.
- Who arranges cargo insurance, and at what cover.
- The export declaration and its value basis.
- What happens if the container misses the vessel — who bears the rebooking.
And one more that isn't an Incoterm but belongs in the same paragraph: the documents you expect with the shipment. Commercial invoice, packing list, bill of lading, and any certificate your market requires. If you need a certificate of origin or a test report, say so before production — not at the port.
Red flags in a quote
- "FOB" that doesn't include export clearance. That's EXW wearing a different label, and it will surface as a charge later.
- DDP quoted without a duty basis. Ask which HS code and which duty rate the price assumes. A DDP number with no stated basis is a number that can change after the goods land.
- Wildly different prices under the same Incoterm from two suppliers. Before assuming one is cheaper, ask what each includes. The gap is usually in the origin charges.
- A request to declare a lower value than the invoice. This is customs fraud in most jurisdictions, it can void your cargo insurance, and it puts the importer — you — at risk, not the supplier.
- No named place. "FOB" or "CIF" with no port is not a term.
The short version
An Incoterm decides who pays each cost and where risk transfers. It does not decide ownership, quality, or price.
- Never compare quotes across different Incoterms. Convert to landed cost first.
- Cost and risk are separate columns. Under CFR and CIF the supplier pays the freight while the risk has already been yours since loading.
- CIF insurance is minimum cover by default, and the claim is yours to file.
- "FOB Ningbo" is a term. "FOB China" is not. Always name the place.
- First order without a forwarder: DDP or DAP. Once you have one: FOB.
The term is not the small print of the quote. It is the part of the quote that determines what the number actually buys.
If you're comparing quotes and want them on the same basis, write to lemon@mtdmj.com and tell us your destination port and whether you have a forwarder. We quote FOB Guangzhou as standard, and DDP where that's the simpler answer for you. We work on 30/70 terms with a minimum of 100 pieces per style. The questions buyers ask us most are on our FAQ page, and this piece on what 30/70 actually protects covers the payment side of the same conversation. You can also start at mtdmj.com.
MTDMJ (Senhean Garment Co., Ltd.) is a custom apparel manufacturer in Guangzhou, China. We have been making garments since 2003 — twenty-three years and more than 900 clients later, in our own factory, with our own sample room, cutting room and export team. We work on a quote basis, with a minimum of 100 pieces per style and 30/70 payment terms. We make custom T-shirts, dresses, shirts and hoodies.
Keep the conversation going. We share sourcing notes, factory-floor detail and buyer guides on LinkedIn, Facebook and Medium. If you're planning an order, write to lemon@mtdmj.com.
0 comments